'He's the new Daniel Day-Lewis': Margot Robbie defends Jacob Elordi's Heathcliff in Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights

Margot Robbie comes to defence of Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff in Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights adaptation, saying "he is Heathcliff" and likening him to Daniel Day-Lewis. The film has faced criticism over its casting and changes made by Fennell, particularly regarding Elordi's character description as "dark-skinned" and a "lascar".

Fennell, known for her provocative and socially charged storytelling, appears to be employing similar tactics with Wuthering Heights. Early test screenings have described the film as "aggressively provocative and tonally abrasive", featuring a scene of a public hanging that includes graphic content.

Robbie, who is also producing the film through her production company LuckyChap, defends Fennell's approach, saying that Brontë's novel is very personal and illicit material. She also addresses concerns about the casting of Robbie herself in the role of Cathy, which has been described as dark-haired and in her late teens, but has blonde hair in the trailer.

Robbie describes Fennell's vision for Wuthering Heights as an "act of extreme masochism" to adapt such a personal and provocative book. She notes that the film is not just about sex or provocation, but rather epic romance. On set, Robbie recalled discussions with Fennell about what reads as sexy or exciting, saying "it's not just a sex position or someone taking their shirt off".

The production company behind Wuthering Heights is LuckyChap, which has emerged as an entertainment industry force through its credits on films like Barbie and I, Tonya. The film's release has generated significant buzz, with Robbie and Fennell hoping to make "this generation's Titanic".

I'm not sure about this Wuthering Heights adaptation ... Margot Robbie comes in to defend Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff, but I gotta say, I've got my doubts . The whole 'dark-skinned' and 'lascar' thing just seems like a weird choice to me . And what's up with the graphic content in the film? Can't they just tone it down a notch?

And Margot, I get that Emily Brontë's novel is personal and all that, but does it really need to be so... provocative? Fennell's vision for this epic romance thing seems like a stretch to me . And what about the casting of herself as Cathy? Like, it's not just about the hair or age, it's about who she actually is in the role .

I'm all for taking risks with film adaptations, but sometimes I think they go too far . This one feels like it's trying to be a bit too edgy and trendy . Give me a good old-fashioned romance any day

I'm loving the drama that's going down around Emerald Fennell's Wuthering Heights adaptation . Margot Robbie coming to Jacob Elordi's defense as Heathcliff is totally fair - he does seem like a great fit for the role, and comparing him to Daniel Day-Lewis is on point . I can see why people would be upset about the casting changes, but it sounds like Fennell has a clear vision for this film, even if it's not everyone's cup of tea .

I think what really gets my attention is Robbie's statement that Brontë's novel is "very personal and illicit material" . It's so true - Wuthering Heights does explore some heavy themes like class, love, and revenge, which can be pretty intense for viewers. But I also appreciate her distinction between Fennell's approach being provocative and just plain sexy .

The fact that the film is getting so much buzz is a good sign for LuckyChap - they're definitely making waves in the entertainment industry ! And let's be real, who doesn't want to see Margot Robbie as Cathy? She does seem like she'd bring a lot of depth and nuance to the role . Overall, I'm excited to see how this film plays out - it sounds like it could be something really special

I think Margot Robbie is totally on point here . People are always gonna have an opinion about a film adaptation, but let's be real, Jacob Elordi was born to play Heathcliff. I mean, the guy's got the whole brooding thing down pat . And let's not forget, Daniel Day-Lewis is like the ultimate Heathcliff, so comparing them isn't too far off for me . As for the controversy surrounding Elordi's casting, I think Margot's right, it's about time we saw some diversity in these classic roles. And yeah, I'm a bit curious to see how this film all comes together, especially that public hanging scene... but hey, if it's as epic and romantic as Margot says, I'll be there for it .

omg you guys i feel like emerald fennell is trying too hard with her wuthering heights adaptation she's like that one aunt who just wont let go lol, rememberring how intense the 1992 film was with kiefer sutherland as heathcliff, but honestly margot robbie defending her vision is kinda cool, its like jacob elordi is gonna be the new it guy, reminds me of when daniel day-lewis first started out, that intense brooding look and can we talk about how Robbie herself just got typecast as a blonde cathy, remember how julianne moore was all dark-haired and edgy in the 90s? anyway, i guess wuthering heights is gonna be big, like titanic or something

I'm kinda on board with this bold adaptation of Wuthering Heights but, gotta say, some casting decisions still got me thinking . I mean, Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff? It's a risk, right? But at the same time, Margot Robbie is totally right about Emily Brontë's novel being super personal and raw . I just wish Fennell had been more considerate of the cultural context surrounding Heathcliff's character description .

And can we talk about that public hanging scene for a sec? It sounds like it's gonna be pretty intense . But, I gotta ask, is it really necessary? Robbie does make some good points about Fennell's vision being an "act of extreme masochism" to adapt the book , but at what cost?

I mean, come on . The whole 'emerging as a force' thing is just code for "we're cheap but we'll churn out a ton of content quickly" . But hey, at least Margot Robbie is standing up for Jacob Elordi's casting choices, even if it means having to address some awkward stereotypes . And I'm not saying it's bad that the film is trying to be provocative - but 'aggressively abrasive' is a pretty strong phrase . I guess what I'm saying is that Wuthering Heights might just be more than just sex and violence... but don't hold your breath for some epic romance . Still, you have to respect Margot's dedication to the project - at least she's not afraid of controversy .

omg u guys i am literally SHAKING with excitement about this new wuthering heights adaptation!!! margot robbie comes for jacob elordi as heathcliff like NO EXCUSES and i am HERE. FOR. IT!!! her defense of fennell's approach is EVERYTHING - she gets that the book is super personal and illicit, and that's what makes it so raw and epic

and can we talk about the casting controversy? dark-skinned heathcliff? lascar? come on! i think they got it right, and if people can't handle a little diversity in their period dramas then maybe they should be watching someone else's movie

robie's comments about fennell's vision are also giving me LIFE - this is not just some titillating romp, but an act of EXTREME MASOCHISM to bring the book to life and i am HERE. for that

and let's be real... margot robbie in cathy? YES PLEASE!!! i love her in barbie and irodya tonya and she's going to BRING THE HEAT as cathy

I'm curious how they're gonna pull off this one . Casting changes can be wild, but dark-skinned Heathcliff is definitely a departure from the classic pic... I mean, what's next? Dark-haired Cathy? I guess it's all about Fennell's vision and making this Wuthering Heights her own, and if that means pushing boundaries, then so be it . Robbie's support for Fennell's approach is interesting – does she think we're ready for this kind of raw, unapologetic adaptation? Either way, I'm intrigued to see how this plays out on the big screen...

idk why ppl are so worked up about the casting in wuthering heights adaptation ugh, cant we just enjoy the movie without being like "oh my god, its not what i expected"? like margot robbie is literally trying to defend emerald fennell's vision and her approach to storytelling isn't even that provocative... its just a movie, ppl

OMG, i think margot robbie is TOTALLY RIGHT about emerald fennell's approach to wuthering heights!!! she knows that the book is all about heathcliff and cathy's dark past and how it affects them, so yeah, if you're gonna do it, DO IT PROPERLY!!! i mean, who cares what people think about the casting, it's a classic novel for a reason! besides, emerald fennell is like a genius or something, always pushing boundaries and making art that sparks conversations. let's be real, wuthering heights needs to be made in 2025 or we're gonna lose our minds!!!

idk why ppl are so salty about the casting tho i mean margot robbie is def cathy in that trailer lol and jacob elordi as heathcliff? i think its actually kinda cool how they're making him dark-skinned, it adds a new layer to the character. emerald fennell's gotta be doing something right if she's getting ppl so worked up and honestly, i'm down for some provocative wuthering heights, we need more epic romances in our lives

I'm not sure about Margot Robbie defending Jacob Elordi's casting as Heathcliff... I mean, I get where she's coming from, but isn't it kinda important to represent the characters accurately? The controversy around Elordi's dark skin tone and the film's changes have been pretty valid concerns. Maybe instead of saying he "is" Heathcliff, they could've had a more nuanced discussion about representation and diversity?

omg u guys, im so down for margot robbie defendin jacob elordi as heathcliff in emerald fennells wuthering heights adaptation! i think its kinda cool that she's standin up for him against all the hate. and yeah, i can see why ppl would be upset about the casting, especially with the lascar description, but i think fennell is tryin to bring somethin new to the table.

i love how robbie is describin it as an "act of extreme masochism" - like, she's embracin the controversy and not afraid to speak her mind. and its not just about sex or provocation, its about takin on a classic novel that ppl might think is too intense. i mean, who hasn't had a crush on heathcliff at some point?

anyway, im so hyped for this film now! i think the trailer was kinda underwhelming, but with fennell and robbie at the helm, im expectin somethin epic. let's get ready to ship cathy and heathcliff all over again

OMG I'm so hyped for this Wuthering Heights adaptation!!! Margot Robbie defending Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff is like, totally fair . The guy does look like he could be the brooding Heathcliff . And can we talk about how LuckyChap Productions is killing the game? They've already had such awesome films under their belt and now this one?! I'm here for it!

OMG what's going on with this new Wuthering Heights adaptation ?! I'm all about Margot Robbie defending Jacob Elordi as Heathcliff, but like can't they just get the casting right first? And those test screenings sound HELLUVA rough! I mean, who thought it was a good idea to include graphic content in a public hanging scene?

But, you know, I do love how Margot's sticking up for Emerald Fennell's vision - it's like she gets that the book is all about Catherine and Heathcliff's complex and dark romance . And can we talk about how LuckyChap is killing the game right now? Barbie and I, Tonya were so fire! This Wuthering Heights adaptation better be just as lit

I'm still a bit skeptical about the blonde Cathy look tho... Margot's dark hair in real life, but in the trailer it's all golden . Anyway, can't wait to see what Fennell and Robbie have cooked up for us!

idk why they need to make it so dark & provocative... i mean, i love emerald fennell but can't she just stick to the story? it sounds like jacob elordi is being typecast as a lascar and it's not fair. margot robbie is trying to defend him but i think she's missing the point. i get that wuthering heights is a classic book, but does it need to be turned into some kind of twisted soap opera? also, what's up with the public hanging scene? can't they just leave that part out?

im not buying margot robbie's attempt to spin emerald fennell's wuthering heights adaptation as some kinda artistic vision the whole thing just seems like a messy, over-hyped disaster waiting to happen. and honestly, i think jacob elordi is actually pretty miscast as heathcliff... can't we just stick with a more traditional portrayal of the character?

omg i feel u about this adaptation lol Jacob Elordi is literally perfect for Heathcliff in my book and Margot Robbie is being sooo supportive of Emerald Fennell's vision its beautiful how they're standing by each other , but at the same time im a little worried about that public hanging scene... graphic content can be super triggering , idk what to think about it yet. lets just say i'm hyped for the film and cant wait to see how it all comes together

idk what all the fuss is about, but imo margot robbie getting defensive for jacob elordi as heathcliff makes sense . like, brontë's novel is pretty provocative and fennell's vision might be a bit too on the nose? but at least its not just some watered down rom-com adaptation... that would be a travesty . i love that robbie is standing by her girl emerald fennell, even if it means being seen as "defensive" . and tbh, elordi's casting as heathcliff does raise some eyebrows... but maybe thats just me ?